Our 1980 dishwasher isn't getting anything clean. Has anyone bought a decent dishwasher lately for a reasonable price? I don't want to overpay, but also don't want to buy a piece of garbage.
I haven't bought anything but my "appliance guy" said that if you could do it he liked Bosch............other than that he was 'pretty much' a Whirlpool guy or Kitchen Aid............but I would check their recent reputation before buying.............
If I ever get around to my kitchen remodel I will probably look at Kitchen Aid............if it is still around..........:laugh: (the thought of the MESS makes me cringe!!)
I'm right in the middle of a kitchen remodel myself.
Frugalfranny - You're so right about the mess, but I'm using it as an excuse to not clean the rest of the house! Even with doors closed and plastic over the kitchen openings, dust seeps in or gets tracked everywhere.
As for the dishwasher, I'm going with Whirlpool. The model I'm getting is WDF510PAYS.
I read all the reviews and they were good. The one I'm replacing was a Maytag and I was never impressed with it.
I'm not sure of the regular price. I'm getting mine pretty cheap because I'm buying all new appliances and they gave me the contractor's price - $352.
There is a Bosch on sale right now for a decent price, maybe we'll go in tonight and see what's in stock. KitchenAid is sooo expensive - although the old one is a KitchenAid so that's a pretty good testament to it's quality.
My old one was a KitchenAid too.........GOLD......so that tells you how old it was. I am just hoping their 'quality' hasn't gone down. Wow, I didn't realize that Bosch was cheaper than KitcheAid............might change my mind when ..........and if........it ever comes time to actually SHOP! The replacement was a cheap one and sucks......super noisy and wouldn't have another---Roper!
All these postings about new appliances and remodels are making me want to dive in.......now, if I could just disappear for a couple months and then come home and it would all be done!!! :laugh: OH............and CLEANED UP TOO!!
I've bought two dishwashers in the last few years (different houses) and I'm about to buy a third in the next few years.
Dishwashers are divided in two categories: integral garbage disposal or no garbage disposal. I prefer the dishwashers with garbage disposal. They are louder and take more energy but I really dislike having to remember to empty the trap in the disposal-less models. However, if you are searching for whisper quiet (like if your kitchen is open to a living room), then select one without a disposal. Some people also buy dishwashers without a disposal because they're on a septic system. However, I've had garbage disposals both in the dishwasher and the sink on a septic system for years and years without any problems. As a matter of fact, I suspect not having a garbage disposal is causing me more problems (I don't have one currently and we're going to add one soon).
Once you make the decision between garbage disposal or no, I don't have a lot of requirements. I prefer a certain lay-out inside my dishwasher so that eliminates certain brands. I like the upper rack to adjust up and down - making room for wineglasses on top or big platters on the bottom. I also like the lower rack tines to lay flat to make room for odd items like the big metal air filters on my furnace. Of course, I want a good Energy Star rating, too.
Over all, I stay away from Kenmore (OMG! We started out buying a Kenmore and after wires burning on THREE that got installed we finally just bought a different brand!) and Frigidaire. KitchenAid, Whirlpool, GE, Maytag, Bosch, LG, and Fisher & Paykel all make decent dishwashers. As a matter of fact, some of them are made by the same company but just have a different name on the front.
When selecting a dishwasher, I started with the cheapest model and looking at the next price up until it became obvious that the extra bells and whistles weren't worth the money anymore. I DO like a stainless steel interior. I don't like the control panel at the top of the door (under the rim of the counter). I prefer a separate locking lever - although I currently have a dishwasher without one and it is okay. But all those "features" are personal preferences in my mind.
When it comes to price, I usually find something I like that costs $6XX (like $685) before tax. DEFINITELY have the store arrange a contractor to install the dishwasher. I promise you that I've installed a lot of appliances of all sorts and a dishwasher is just one of those things that I refuse to do myself - just too many things I can do wrong and end up causing a ton of damage when I do.
I have a Bosch. We replaced the Whirlpool Gold that was in the house when we bought it (I hated it!) Love the Bosch and it is SUPER quiet and uses about 5 gallons of water.
I been searching today and found that the #1 rated is the Samsung DMT800RHS
$799. @ Lowes. plus tx. and an intake hose.-
-stainless steel exterior
-energy star rebate
-hidden controls
-concealed heat element
-sm. leak detecter w/ shut off
-quietest
-stainless steel interior
Everyone says buy the extended warranty as the parts are cheap on all the reveiws I have read.
Tomorrow I will go to Lowes and actually see the unit. I buy online to save but ALWAYS see the physical unit if poss.
I looked at all the models that the were recalled and caught fire and this wasnt listed.
I personally hate Samsung products. We had a really bad experience with a TV that we bought from them. The repair process was eye-opening (it should have been replaced but they refused). We vowed to not buy from them ever again. My husband works in international electronics development so is very familiar with Samsung and how they operate. They don't have the greatest reputation on many levels.
Never bought too much from them all I know is what consumer said. They gave them a near perfect rating.
I personally think most things are crap these days but if you want one-choose away.
The whirlpool I got last year wont wash the bottom and the techs cant tell DH whats wrong.
We have the Fisher Pikel with two drawers. My husband has had to repair it several times in five years. It only uses powder detergent. And I have to clean them every three weeks or so. Yes, I have to clean the dishwasher! Will never buy this product
We did our kitchen reno 4 years ago and replaced our 1985 dishwasher with a Kitchen Aid and I HATE it! It was expensive, all stainless steel inside and out, has all the bells and whistles but it doesn't clean the dishes! It makes me crazy and to be honest I end up washing the dishes by hand most days! We should have researched more and made a smarter choice, but we didn't!
I was on the Lowes website for another reason and saw several dishwashers for $599 that looked like ones that I would buy if I had to make the purchase today.
We have a Frigidaire dishwasher that we bought 3 years ago. It is awful! It is so loud that we have started running it only when we are upstairs in bed at night or away from home. It takes about 2 hours to run a load too. I don't know if that is normal but it seems like forever because of the noise. I dream of the day that we can replace it.
Cookielee-careful some of the cheap dishwasher dont have heat coils so you are letting the dishes drip dry. And the insides are not stainless steel. Etc.
Frugalwarrior, are you in Canada? Maybe that is the difference. I'm in the USA and I typically pay between $600 and $700 for a really, really good dishwasher. Over $1000 for a dishwasher? Those are for status. I can get wonderful steam cleaning and a stainless steel interior with a terrific Energy Star rating and quiet function for less than $1000.
Monkeywrangler, you may want to re-think your desire and need for a new dishwasher after reading this article. In fact, we might all want to just start washing our dishes down at the creek. :lol3:
The irony of this article has me just shaking my head and laughing.
I thought my dishwasher was giving me trouble getting things clean but it turns out to be the new non-phosphate detergent. GRRRR, found an old box tucked in back of a closet and gave it a try. Nice and clean. *sigh*
I bought a whirlpool gold with the metal interior and potscrubber. I am pleased with it. It was on sale and I got a movers packet from the post office and used the lowes coupon 10 percent (I think).
I had a kenmore when I moved into my house 10 years ago, that was very old and came with the house. Within three years, I replaced it with a Kenmore I bought gently used (about 2-3 yrs old, but barely used) off of craigslist for $200. It lasted 7 years and did a pretty good job - not great on pans. I am now getting ready to sell my house and my dishwasher just broke, so I didn't want to spend much money on a new one. I went to Sears and got another Kenmore, a basic one for about $300. So far it's not too noisy and it does a better job on pans than my last one. I'm not super picky about dishes or dishwashers. I've had it about a month and I'm happy with it. I don't use a finishing rinse and even so the dishes come out very clean.
MW - have you made a purchase since starting this thread?
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Frugal Village Forums
1.8M posts
47.5K members
Since 2001
A forum community dedicated to the frugal lifestyle and the enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about simple and green living, cost effective tips, life hacks, debt reduction, recycling, gardening, other homesteading techniques, and more!