Frugal Village Forums banner

Alternative to Dave Ramsey's Deluxe Envelope System?

21K views 24 replies 23 participants last post by  luckbethislady 
#1 ·
I saw that there is a sale on some of Dave Ramsey's products at his webstie with something like $4.95 shipping. Does anyone know if there is something similar out there for a lower price? Or have you just created your own system?

Thanks!
 
#6 ·
Are you looking for something that you will carry around and use as a wallet or will it be at home for organizing the budget and storing the money?

I found that the paper envelopes really didn't hold up as long as I would have liked when we started following DR but I used it as a wallet. I've re-purposed that to the budget box and store the money that I do NOT carry around. (These are the envelopes we may open once or twice a month - like blow money, leisure/entertainment, etc, and I have supplemented it with office envelopes as well.)

We did get the deluxe wallet Deluxe Wallet Envelope System for me to carry around and I LOVE IT!

There are plenty of slots for me to organize and carry part of my grocery, HBA, dining out, household, and part of our leisure funds. As well as slots for my debit card and grocery club cards, a zippered coin pouch, and large slots for check book size items. My only dislike about it is the "envelope" section is pre-labled by embossing.... no color so the words are in little letters black on black. My eyes are over 45 years old and I can't see it!!! I used sticky back labels to make the category names larger and contrasting :).

I haven't really found anything less expensive for the quality of the deluxe wallet. :( But for home organizing, I would make my own system instead of investing in the DR paper envelopes again. :)

I really hope that helps.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AspiringToBeFrugal
#7 ·
Like Cea, I have the DR deluxe wallet system (got on sale a couple of Christmases ago) and I use it non-stop (STILL on the envelope system even on the other side of debt). I still have the original pen that came with the kit and used it to write that check that paid off my last bill to be debt free. It has a sentimental value now. When I run out of room to write on the provided envelops that come with the wallet, I just put blank label stock over the entire face of it and start over, which allows me to recycle the envelopes until they're worn out.
 
#8 ·
I got a fabric envelope wallet off of etsy. It is super cute and you can have the envelopes personalized with whatever labels you want. Instead of a real wallet, since I already had a really nice (large, zip up) wallet, I had her make me an insert of 3 envelopes sewn together that I could use to just insert into my own wallet and had labeled with the 3 categories I use the most. For the other categories I dont use as much, I use jars at home (Gail Val Oxelade style).
 
#9 ·
i bought fabric ones off etsy but they must have measured the dollar bill cut out the fabric and then sewed it so it was too small .

i won a savvycents wallet from here and its great but bright pink and although i love that color i like to swap things out with season changes .

unwilling to spend the money on another savvycents ( if they had another color i really liked i might as a gift for my birthday etc i like it that much )


JCP has wallets that have an area for dividing money into categories also - but i took a wallet i already had that had a few areas in it
i took a fine tipped premanent marker and marked one little slot for ID cards " gas " - a second one " gifts" and i can fold up money and put it in slots
main cash area is for my spending money - another full length area is for food ,

any other money IE saving for holiday gifts - etc stays at home in a regular envie

My emergency fund and areas for medical entertainment vacations or someting big we are saving for all go into checking acct . i have quicken and have made several categories in quicken to house these things . even though it may look like i have more in my checking acct i know to only go by the acct we use for regular checking as what we have available ,

sounds confusing but have done it this way for years !
 
#12 ·
#15 ·
I do simple nylon pencil pouches with zippers...and right now you'll be able to find them for less than a $1.00 a piece while school supplies will be on sale.

Yes it costs a bit more than a regular envelope but they also last soooo much longer as well and I like that they are big enough to put receipts in without everything falling out.
Also handy if you have loose change that you want to put back into your envelopes {we don't do this, we have a change jar that we add the leftover change to}.

I just pop them into a regular notebook binder and we go and pull from them before we head out to run errands/go shopping...then whatever is left over we add back in once we get home.
I mean you could just as easily take the entire pencil pouch along with you in your purse or whatnot but this is just the way we do it

I picked different colored pencil pouches for each of my budget categories so all in all I think I have 8 or 9 of them in my binder. Just flip the cardboard over that comes in them & write the budget category on the back side.:heartsm:
 
#17 ·
These are great ideas!

I just use reg paper envelopes.

I really like the idea of the zippered pencil pouches! They will hold more, and change, and receipts! I think I'll try that!
 
#18 ·
I used to use the envelop system and it's a great tool to help you train yourself to spend wisely and within your budget.

I just used paper envelops I got free from the bank. (those tan ones)

However, over time, I developed a system that is an electronic version of paper envelopes. Every week I dump the expected budgeted amount into the electronic envelop and it calculates my running total available for me to spend.

It works for me. I don't carry cash, except for my alloted $20/week free spending amount.
Everything is done by debit card and deducted from the category.

If I go over on a category, I have to take from another category to balance it out. It's like robbing from Peter to pay Paul.

It might seem complicated, but it's really not. I just don't use cash anymore.

However, I wished I new about the pencil holder pouches and the coupon divider. I would have used that! great ideas!

Cheers!
 
#21 ·
Like FN I use my debit card for almost everything. I use Excel to track my envelope balances. Every payday I put 1/4 of the amount in each envelope. Then on the lucky months that I have 5 paydays I'm putting that into my 6 mo EF. Once that is fully funded I will use the extra payday to pay off debt.
 
#23 ·
I just returned back to "cash only" (except for those bills that must be by check or debit). I
just bought this nifty wallet - Black & White Wallet | Thrifty Zippers

I can't wait to get it so I can start loading in the cash into it.

Of course, there's the paper envelopes, or the envelopes you can make yourself with craft/scrapbook paper which I could do as well, but I wanted something I could put my checkbook, license, debit card, etc into and... I didn't have the time to make anything.

So, I bought for the sheer fun of it.
 
#24 ·
I make mine out of cardstock paper. I have a wallet with a zipper area and then a separate area meant for a checkbook that snaps...that's where I keep my envelopes.

FN - I've looked at those wallets so many times! I want one so badly! Let me know how you like it!
 
#25 ·
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top